Are Steel Toe Boots Comfortable?
You wear a protective boot for the safety of your feet. They protect you from the damage caused due to falling objects, and also compression or rolling damage. Besides protecting you from damage, these boots are also oil and slip-resistant and prevent slippage in other wet surfaces. These are abrasion-proof and insulated as well, both electrically and thermally.
But the question remains: is the boot comfortable? The comfortability of a boot depends on various factors.
The material used to make the boot determines its comfort. Generally, protective boots are made of leather. Genuine leather boots are very comfortable.
These are a layer of cushioning placed inside your boot. A good quality insole has a thick layer of cushioning. The four most commonly used materials used for making an insole are foam, gel, leather, and cork. These provide cushioning to your feet. It also absorbs the shock produced while walking. So, if you are looking for comfort, go for a boot with a good quality insole.
When you wear the boot for longer durations, your feet might get sweaty. A breathable boot is a boot that allows proper air circulation inside the boot. It keeps your feet dry by letting the perspiration evaporate through its membrane. This keeps your feet dry and fresh. So, breathability is a determining factor that determines the comfortability of your boot.
4. Arch Support:
Our body is designed in such a way that our entire body weight is distributed equally on our feet. This correct posture puts equal pressure on the foot. Using a wrong boot can disrupt this posture and cause stress to our feet. We get tired easily due to this fact, and our feet may start to hurt. This problem can be overcome by using arch support. A safety boot with proper arch support maintains the balance of our feet. It ensures that the bodyweight is equally distributed throughout our feet. So you should look out for a boot with proper arch support that is comfortable to you.
5. Safety Toe:
A safety toe is a layer or covering that protects our toe. It is usually made of iron, or an alloy, or some other composite materials. The main task of a safety toe is to safeguard our toe from any possible damage.
The fitting of a safety boot is important. You cannot break in a safety boot as you do with regular leather shoes. This is due to the fact that these are hardened to withstand extreme conditions and protect our feet from damage. So, it won’t stretch, no matter how many times you try or wear it. So, if you are going to purchase a safety boot, make sure that you purchase the one that fits perfectly to you. It is recommended to try out these boots during the evening, as our feet tend to expand through the course of the day, and are at the largest size in the evening. Also, while trying the boots, do wear socks which you will wear during working. This way you’ll get to know whether the boot is tight or loose or fits perfectly.
It’s an external factor, but it’s an important one. A good pair of socks can provide comfort even in the most uncomfortable boots.
We recommend you to choose a pair that is comfortable and soft on your feet. This way, it will provide comfort to your feet.
While it is clear about the other factors regarding the comfortability of a safety boot, the safety toe has some misconceptions about it. Some say that a steel toe is comfortable, while others may differ. Before we discuss whether a steel toe is comfortable or not, let us first know what a steel toe is.
Steel Safety Toe
As the name suggests, these are made up entirely of steel. These steel safety toes were first introduced in the 1930s, it still remains a popular choice today. This is because they provide maximum protection. Although an alloy safety toe or a composite safety toe matches the ASTM standards, it cannot simply provide the level of protection that a steel safety toe can.
Since steel is available in abundance, these safety toes are cheaper to make, thus making the price of the boot cost-effective. Other safety toes such as an alloy toe or a composite toe are comparatively expensive.
These are heavier. A steel toe can be as much as 30-50% heavier when compared to an alloy toe. Steel Toe is also comparatively heavier compared to a composite toe. This reduces our mobility as compared to other safety toes. Also, since its heavier, it will consume more energy and make us easily fatigue if compared with an alloy or a composite steel toe.
It is thicker than an alloy safety toe and thinner than a composite toe. The increasing order of the thickness of safety toes is: Alloy Toe < Steel Toe < Composite Toe. So, a steel toe will not take up as much space as a composite toe. This provides a little extra space for our toe.
When it comes to protection, all types of safety toe need to pass some standards certified by ASTM. While every safety toe will protect you from workplace hazards, steel toes will provide the best protection. It has the highest shock absorption for damage caused due to falling objects. Those objects could be heavy machinery or tools, or some sharp objects. Safety toe may not safeguard you completely, but it will still prevent your toe from getting seriously damaged. It also provides maximum resistance against compression. It has a high level of capacity to withstand a huge amount of pressure. Needless to say, your toe will be protected if you hit it somewhere.
Since steel is a good conductor of electricity, it may allow the flow of current through your body. To prevent you from electrical shocks, these steel safety boots are covered with a layer of insulation, both on the outside as well as inside. This is done to protect you from electrocution.
Steel is also a good conductor of heat. So, in extremely cold conditions, it will allow your body heat to escape through your feet. This might make your feet getting chilled. Also, in extremely hot conditions, steel toes will get warmed up easily. It will cause your feet to get hot easily. To prevent such an uneventful exchange of heat energy, the boots are covered with a layer of insulation. This makes up for the heat exchange caused due to the steel safety toes.
We know that the comfortability of a boot does not solely depend on the safety toe. However, if you find your steel safety toe to be uncomfortable, you can use the following tips and tricks to provide comfort to your feet.
- Use the right pair of socks. Some socks are specifically designed for steel toes. These have a thicker layer near the heels and toes. The extra layer of cushioning can make your boot fit perfectly, and provide comfort.
- Buy a good quality insole. Before purchasing an insole, you will have to make sure that the boots you buy have a removable insole. An external pair of insoles can provide the right amount of cushioning and provide comfort to your feet. So, invest in a proper insole if you feel that the ones in your boot are not up to the mark.
- Break-in your steel toe boot. It is nearly impossible to break in steel toe boots using normal methods that we use for a regular boot. There are specific techniques like Stick Method, Oil Method, Hot Water Method, and Cold-Water Treatment. Using these techniques, you can break in your boots, so that it might be comfortable to wear later on.
- Using bandages can help a lot too. Wrap bandages around specific areas of your feet that feel discomforted. This is done so as to prevent the development of blisters, especially during the break-in period.
Steel toes by itself is not the major factor deciding the comfortability of the boot. You should focus on other features like the insole, arch support, material of the boot to buy a boot that’s comfortable.
However, if we are to focus only on steel toes, then we might say that although it provides the best protection, it has some drawbacks as well. These are heavier when compared to alloy and composite safety toes, which results in lesser mobility and greater fatigue. These steel toes are not thermally insulated, which results in the loss of body heat in extremely cold conditions while heating up faster in extremely hot conditions. Under normal circumstances, a steel toe boots is comfortable enough. Even if it’s not, there are ways with the help of which we make the boots comfortable. My advice will be to invest in a steel toe boots that has a good quality insole, provides arch support, and is breathable as well. For better comfort, wear a pair of socks designed especially for the steel toe safety boots, as it has a better level of cushioning. If these factors are kept in mind, then be ensured that your steel toe boots will be comfortable to wear. Now you don’t need to be worried about choosing the right safety boot for yourself.